Two Witnesses | Not Two Stories | Exposing the Flawed Logic of Modern Legal Gatekeepers
There is a dangerous kind of blindness that happens when men sit in elevated seats, cloaked in titles such as Moreh, and decide that their status gives them immunity from basic logic. We see it all the time in our congregations and online: a woman brings forward a sound, text-backed observation, and instead of engaging the text, the "experts" dismiss it with a wave of the hand. Arrogance loves a title, but pride hates the truth when the truth exposes its sloppy scholarship. The debate centers around a foundational pillar of Torah law: the requirement of multiple witnesses. Too many self-appointed leaders are running around teaching a dangerous, social media-style jurisprudence, claiming that if one person sees a wrong done on Monday, and another person sees a similar wrong done on Thursday, by the same person, you can smash those two separate incidents together and call it a "two-witness rule.” One Moreh claimed that this nonsense applied to the Bill Cosby conviction, wh...